Search The Civil Litigator

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Reconsideration of a claim - especially stale claim

2008 10 SCC 115

Limitation: don't get hypertechnical

Don't get hyper technical, see and try to decide matters on merit. From the conduct of the of the party it can't be said that it had been absolutely callous and negligent.. It prosecuted the matter after it became aware of the non-appearance of its advocate. 2010 6 SCC 786
--------------------------------------
Sent from handheld device

Limitation

Not filing separate application for condonation of delay is not consequential if otherwise averments are made and sufficient cause is there
(2010) 12 SCC 159
--------------------------------------
Sent from handheld device

Monday, September 12, 2011

Nexus with cause of accident and reason for repudiation of claim

In absence of a nexus between license of a driver and the accident, insurer would not be liable to allow claim on non-standard basis. United India Insurance Company v. Gaj Pal Singh Rawat, 2010 NCJ 37 (NC)



Limitation: Whether or not pleaded, court is bound to consider as a preliminary question

State Bank of India v. BS Agricultural Industries Limited, (2009) 5 SCC 121

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Government Servant is not 'consumer' qua the government

The Complainant was not a consumer as he has not hired the services of the Central  Government for any purpose whatsoever nor he purchased anything so as to bring his status within the category of 'consumer'. As a matter of fact he himself rendered services to the Central Government in lieu of consideration. 


1 (2011) CPJ 473, para 18

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Banking Ombudsman & Consumer Forum

Consumer after claiming relief in front of Banking Ombudsman can approach Consumer Fora 
IV (2010) CPJ 315